Yet when Konersman took to the stage the night before our interview, he immediately captured the room with perfectly timed jokes propelled by an honest and enthusiastic personality. “Hey, welcome!” he would shout at every newcomer to the bar, and whenever someone ordered a round of shots, Konersman would suddenly stop whatever song he was playing, put down his guitar and blast “Shots” by Lil John from his pre-programmed iPod. And all the while he was smiling from ear to ear even when he was singing. For the audience, there is something charming about Jay Bangles the performer. It wasn’t long before people were swaying back and forth to his mix of everything from modern country to ’90s alternative and sincerely laughing along with his cheeky humor.
“So, should I call you Jared or Jay?” I ask him.
“Either one” he says with an easy shrug. He then goes on to explain to me that Jay Bangles is a stage name that he acquired in his hometown of St. Louis but gave up for a little bit. When Konersman moved to Key West he decided to feel out the music scene before committing to an identity. His days of playing with a punk rock band in a city plagued by “many problems” were quite different than this island he is now living in. However, he recently revived the persona in memory of a fellow local musician and is now once again known around town as the much easier to pronounce Jay Bangles. “My dear friend who passed away three years ago gave it to me and I wanted to honor him.”
On his 13th birthday Konersman asked his Dad for a drum set and got a guitar. Nevertheless, he eagerly enrolled in two years’ worth of lessons and practiced so much that by the time he was 15 he had mastered entire albums from front to back. Naturally, after building such an impressive repertoire, the next step would be to join a band, an acappella quartet, the choir, and become the president of the art club.
Then, after all of that, it would only make sense to receive a phone call from a place hundreds of miles away asking if he would like to partake in a five-day audition to be the guitarist for a band somewhere in the middle of paradise. So, he went, driving straight down after flying into Miami on a little bit of sleep and a lot of rattled nerves. He ended up being hired as the bassist, but not before bombing on the first day. He would go on to play with the Durtbags at Durty Harry’s in Rick’s Entertainment Complex from 2010 to 2013 before branching out on his own.
“The audition was super scary and I was very unprepared,” he admits, “but by the fifth day I had learned 20 new songs and I just blew them away. I went back to St. Louis, quit my job, rented out my house, dropped out of school, broke up with my girlfriend and came right back down.”
When Konersman eventu- ally quit the band it was because he was simply looking for something different. The heavy demand on his vocal cords left him with a constant scratch in his throat after too many hours and too many days a week. During one spring break the band played back to back for 42 days in a row. As much as he loved the gig he was pushing himself to the brink of exhaustion. At the end he would give Rick’s a respectable six-week notice before teaming up with drummer Jim Simonian to create the Jay and Jim Show at Irish Kevin’s across the street. He now plays a regular three to four hour schedule on Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Sunday and Monday at 11 p.m. with a few random gigs in between. He tells me that he has no immediate plans to leave Key West or Irish Kevin’s. He truly likes what he does and it shows when he plays.
“My show is specifically catered to the crowd” konersman explains, “I understand when people want to relax and chill, but if there’s a moment for attention, I’ll take it. I always make sure to ask people how they are doing and to do energetic crowd pleasers that are positive. My set is request heavy. I have 400-500 songs in my catalogue. I’ll play anything if I know it, but I try to stay away from depressing songs at all costs. Anyways, it’s better for bar sales.”
Although Konersman effortlessly maintains a carefree attitude, for him music is a very serious thing. In essence it has defined his life. It has brought him from one place to the next and helps him to pay the bills and then some. He recently traveled through Japan on a motorcycle and just a month ago opened the new Tiki House at 430 Greene Street with a couple of friends and a common vision. He describes the bar as a breath of fresh air.
Taking a stage name is all part of stepping into character, but there is no distinct difference between Jared Konersman the person and Jay Bangles the musician. They are both, without a doubt, worth getting to know. If you are a local and you haven’t had a chance to be charmed by his jokes and enthusiasm , take it from me, it’s about time you do. If you are a tourist, chances are you’ve probably already been there, but if not, then make sure to add a night at Irish Kevin’s to your itinerary. Then let music do its thing.
“If you’re sad it will make you feel better. If you’re in a funk it can take you out if it. Even happy songs can bring you back to a place with tears in your eyes,” Konersman says. “Music is very therapeutic.” ¦