2017-07-13 / Top News

Mel Fisher: Key West's legendary treasure hunter

BY LAURA HACKWORTH
Florida Weekly Correspondent

Indiana Jones. Lara Croft. Jim Hawkins. Jack Sparrow. The allure of the treasure hunting lifestyle is ever-present in literature and film; the familiar tale of the rogue explorer always searching for an historical relic or a treasure buried deep in some remote location inspires children of all ages (and some adults) to draw their own treasure maps and lead their own expeditions to where X marks the spot.

Given its position in the

middle of the ocean, Key West has always been associated with the piratical tradition. But in Key West, treasure hunting is not just relegated to the realm of far-fetched lore and historical nonfiction.

From July 13–15, Key West will celebrate the life of a man who fully adopted the old adage, “Finders keepers.” A man who fought before the Supreme Court to defend his right to finding what he kept, and who followed his dreams relentlessly, impossibly, sure that they would come true if he simply kept at it. Who shared the incredible bounty of his life with family, friends, and strangers. Who dreamt of finding buried treasure more than he dreamt of a desk job — and then had the courage to follow that dream, even when things seemed hopeless. And who, after having lived a life of inconceivable adventure, tenacity, intrigue and bravery, inspired an annual celebration that today raises tens of thousands of dollars for charity. It is the memory of Mr. Fisher, historic treasure hunter, famed dreamer, and one of Key West’s most beloved characters, that the Mel Fisher Days Festival seeks to celebrate.


Mel Fisher’s storied treasure salvage vessel J.B. Magruder. Mel Fisher’s storied treasure salvage vessel J.B. Magruder. Mr. Fisher is perhaps the most legendary treasure hunter in American history. His early years were spent working on a chicken ranch, running the world’s first dive shop, selling lobsters and exploring wrecks underwater alongside his record-setting diver wife, Dorothy, nicknamed Deo. In time, Mr. Fisher and Deo went on to uproot their lives to search for buried treasure in Florida. They developed cutting-edge technology and amassed a crackerjack team of experts, all of whom narrowed their focus to the search for one mysteriously vanished Spanish galleon ship: The Nuestra Señora de Atocha (or, more simply, the Atocha), which sank in 1622 in the waters off the Florida Keys, taking with it over $400 million worth of gold, jewels, armaments, antiquities and those legendary pieces of eight made famous by Disney’s seemingly never-ending Pirates of the Caribbean films (Spanish silver dollars worth a fortune today).


Capt. Andy of the J. B. Magruder. Capt. Andy of the J. B. Magruder. Ms. Fisher and Mr. Fisher had children; the children joined the quest. The family became a kind of Swiss Family Robinson of the treasure salvaging business, spending 16 years and hundreds of thousands of dollars on their quest to unearth the Atocha’s payload. In today’s information driven, instant gratification age, the thought that anyone could spend 16 minutes, let alone 16 years, in pursuit of a singular objective is impressive beyond comprehension, but the Fishers weren’t just any average thrill-seeking family. The Fishers lost a son and daughter-in- law to the search and faced an endless barrage of doubt and ridicule over his refusal to give up hope of finding the ship. He was famously, relentlessly determined, starting each day by telling his crew, “Today’s the day!” It became a credo; they printed it on T-shirts. For over 5,000 days, Mr. Fisher believed that today was the day he would finally achieve his dream. They would find the Atocha, be rich beyond imagination, and his childhood dreams informed by late nights reading Treasure Island in rural Indiana would finally become reality. His quest became the kind of dare-to-dream, impossible-to-win-but-determined-to-anyway story that Hollywood loves to make about injured pitchers getting a second chance at redemption in the major leagues. Today’s the day we find the Atocha! Today’s the day! Outside of his family, his crew, his close friends, and a handful of investors, no one believed he would find it.


The Mel Fisher Expeditions booth. The Mel Fisher Expeditions booth. (Spoiler alert: He found it.)

Mel Fisher Days has grown tremendously since its 1998 conception, during which Mr. Fisher was alive and the festival was able to honor him in person. At the time, it was a small gathering, with hot dogs and discounts on rum and Coke as the main draw. Today, the celebration offers a wider range of events, including tours of the company’s treasure boats and private conservation laboratory, live music, raffles, a silent auction worth tens of thousands of dollars and the chance to bite into a cupcake laced with an authentic Atocha piece of eight. Beginning on Thursday, July 13, and occurring on Friday, July 14, a limited number of ticket holders will get a behind-the-scenes look at the private conservation laboratory of the Fisher family, receiving an intimate look at some of today’s most sophisticated archeological conservation technology (and the millions of dollars’ worth of treasure that it was built to protect). On the afternoon of Saturday, July 15, from 3–9 p.m., locals and visitors will converge at Schooner Warf Bar (one of Mr. Fisher’s favorite drinking haunts — they actually cast his handprints in the concrete), where the storied treasure salvage vessel JB Magruder will dock alongside the bar. Treasure-hunting fans will be able to tour the ship, examining equipment still used in the field and rubbing shoulders with the “Golden Crew” of the original Atocha mother lode discovery. The event is free, open to the public and will also feature live music, food, drinks and contests (including the Lucky Cupcake Contest — those possessing teeth prone to chipping: you’ve been warned). The Schooner Wharf Bar Dock Party will also feature the now-famous silent auction with prizes ranging from authentic treasure to luxurious vacations.


Admiring the treasure. 
NICK DOLL / COURTESY PHOTO Admiring the treasure. NICK DOLL / COURTESY PHOTO 
Treasure hunt winners. Treasure hunt winners. While the company still actively raises funds to finance its current treasure hunting missions, it was decided early on that 100 percent of the festival’s proceeds would go to a Key West charity.

This year’s lucky recipients, Wesley House Family Services, is a charity that Shawn Cowles, one of the original creators of Mel Fisher Days, feels strongly that Mr. Fisher himself would have been proud to support. The charity, which provides services to needy children and families throughout the Keys including foster and adoptive care, intervention services, life skills training and more, exists to protect and provide for the many needy families who utilize its services. During his lifetime, Mr. Fisher had, of course, leaned heavily on the support of his immediate family, his wife and children working tirelessly alongside him, sometimes with heartbreaking results. His son, Kim Fisher, continues his father’s work to this day, searching the ocean surrounding the Keys for the still-undiscovered sections of the Atocha and other valuable wrecks. The Key West community supported Mr. Fisher and his company across 16 years of seemingly-futile searching and fundraising; in helping raise funds for its Key West community (and significant ones at that — last year’s event raised $20,000), the Fisher’s Treasures company is simply helping its family out.

When it comes to the company’s current efforts to uncover buried treasure, Mr. Fisher’s Treasures is constantly investing in and developing new cutting edge technology to aid in their search. Electronic surveys are always underway and modern technology is aiding the current treasure-hunters to identify and locate long-lost ships and recover their treasure. That new technology includes a newly-developed HAUV (that’s a Hybrid Autonomous Underwater Vehicle to you landlubbers), a custom-built research vehicle capable of reaching depths of up to 1,000 meters. Move over, Mars Rover, there’s a new bot in town.

It’s not just the universally-felt lure of riches that makes Mr. Fisher’s story such a powerful one. Indeed, for many, the actual loot of the Atocha is not the most incredible part of the tale. It’s the idea that a person could wake up each day, for an incomprehensible number of days in a row, and tell himself and his crew that today was the day, and that he could believe it just as strongly one morning as the next. In an age of deletable-tweets and five-second attention spans, of lightning-fast information and anonymous internet bullies, this kind of unwavering faith in one’s ability to achieve his or her dreams and to invest the time and effort necessary to do so is practically unheard of. But of equal importance is the endless support and unwavering faith of his crew, his family, and his friends, which enabled Mr. Fisher to achieve his dreams, making the Atocha team just as impressive and legendary a model for humanity as the man behind the find himself. It’s the stuff of fables, of mythical quests and pirates and children’s playground laws. For Mr. Fisher, “Today’s the day” wasn’t simply a credo meant to keep the workers focused. It was how he lived in the present moment. It enabled him to get up each day with the same determination and focus as the day prior. It made every day he woke up important, hope-filled, exceptional. Every day, an opportunity for adventure and success. Every day, the support of his family — both genetic and otherwise — enough to keep him from throwing in the salt water-soaked towel and giving up. Perhaps Mr. Fisher was teaching all of us that each morning, before the day has ground us down to our worst selves, we have the opportunity to curate the valence of our thoughts, to choose to believe we can achieve our dreams or make sure that someone else’s are held afloat for just one more day. And perhaps that’s what Mel Fisher Days is really about, at its core: that today’s the day, for all of us — we just have to remember to live it that way. ¦

— For a complete schedule of events, visit www.MelFisherfisherdays.melfisher.com.

Return to top